Rogue One: Is It the Best Disney Star Wars Movie?
Is Rogue One truly the best Disney Star Wars movie? Director Gareth Edwards stirred up a galactic controversy with his surprising opinion on the film's place in the Star Wars saga. This has reignited the debate among fans about which film reigns supreme in the Disney era of Star Wars.
While George Lucas' original trilogy often tops the charts in terms of Star Wars rankings, Disney's contributions have been more divisive. However, Rogue One has garnered widespread acclaim, positioning it as a fan favorite. But does the film's director this enthusiasm?
Gareth Edwards, the director of Rogue One, revealed to Business Insider that he doesn't necessarily agree with the fan-imposed title of "best Disney Star Wars film." When asked about this perception, Edwards responded, "I don't agree with it, but I appreciate it. I'm very grateful that people say nice things."
This response is particularly intriguing, considering the strong support Rogue One receives from the modern Star Wars fanbase. Given the polarization surrounding the Disney-era sequels, Rogue One has solidified its position as a beloved installment. Edwards' opinion seems to swim against the current of popular sentiment.
Why Doesn't Gareth Edwards Believe Rogue One Is the Best?
The most compelling question stemming from Edwards' statement is the reasoning behind his perspective. Why doesn't he consider Rogue One to be Disney's best Star Wars film? Some might argue that the film wins by default, especially given the often harsh criticism directed at the sequel trilogy.
However, Edwards' answer likely delves deeper. Rogue One underwent substantial reshoots. Tony Gilroy, the creator of the acclaimed Star Wars TV show "Andor," was brought in to rework significant portions of the film's narrative during an extensive reshoot process.
These reshoots were initially shrouded in secrecy, but Gilroy later revealed the extensive nature of the changes, comparing the film to a "corpse" upon his arrival. Edwards also had a cameo in "Star Wars: The Last Jedi," which might indicate a personal preference for that film.
Edwards has consistently expressed respect for the changes made to Rogue One, maintaining that he remained involved throughout the process. However, if Gilroy's account is accurate, Edwards' perception of Rogue One might be influenced by the disparity between the film he initially envisioned and the final product.
The film Edwards set out to create might have differed significantly from the version released in theaters, potentially contributing to his belief that Rogue One isn't Disney's best Star Wars movie.
Our Perspective on Rogue One
Personally, I find myself aligned with Edwards' viewpoint. I believe another Disney Star Wars film holds the top spot, a sentiment that might be considered controversial. Nevertheless, Rogue One remains a stellar film.
For what it's worth, I consider Rogue One to be Disney's second-best Star Wars offering. It boasts exceptional performances, stunning visuals, all the Star Wars Easter eggs a fan could desire, and arguably the best space battle in the entire franchise.
Ultimately, opinions are subjective. Rogue One is undoubtedly a great film, but I don't believe it quite reaches the heights of another Disney Star Wars movie, and it appears Edwards shares a similar sentiment. What do you think? Is Rogue One the best?
The debate surrounding whether Rogue One is the best Disney Star Wars movie continues, fueled by Gareth Edwards' surprising perspective. While opinions may differ, the film's impact and enduring popularity within the Star Wars universe are undeniable.