.webp.webp)
AI in Oscar-Nominated Films Sparks Industry Debate: 'Emilia Perez' and 'The Brutalist' Draw Scrutiny
The 97th Academy Awards finds itself at the intersection of artistic achievement and technological innovation as two critically acclaimed films face scrutiny over their use of artificial intelligence. "Emilia Perez" and "The Brutalist" have secured multiple Oscar nominations while simultaneously igniting a heated debate about AI's role in filmmaking.
Breaking New Ground: The Films and Their Nominations
"Emilia Perez," a groundbreaking musical centered around a Mexican trans cartel leader, has emerged as this year's frontrunner with 13 nominations. Meanwhile, "The Brutalist," which chronicles the story of a Hungarian-Jewish architect who survived the Holocaust, has garnered 10 nominations. Both films are competing in prestigious categories including Best Picture and Best Film Editing.
The nominations extend to individual performances, with Karla Sofía Gascón earning a Best Actress nomination for "Emilia Perez." "The Brutalist" secured acting nominations for Adrien Brody in the Best Actor category and Felicity Jones for Best Supporting Actress.
AI Integration: Innovation Meets Controversy
Both films have implemented AI technology in ways that have sparked industry-wide discussion. "The Brutalist" director Brady Corbet and editor David Jancsó openly acknowledged their use of Respeecher, an AI voice technology, to perfect the Hungarian dialogue pronunciation. The film also employed AI technologies to animate architectural drawings and designs in its climactic scenes.
Similarly, "Emilia Perez" utilized AI to enhance lead actor Gascón's vocal performances in musical sequences, blending their voice with that of a French singer. Sound mixer Cyril Holtz explained that this decision was made to achieve specific vocal ranges necessary for the musical numbers.
Industry Response and Historical Context
The controversy surrounding these films emerges against the backdrop of Hollywood's recent labor disputes. The 2023 strikes by writers and actors unions centered heavily on AI's potential impact on creative workers' rights and compensation. While the Writers Guild of America and SAG-AFTRA reached agreements establishing parameters for AI usage, certain aspects remain contentious, particularly regarding studios' rights to train AI systems using existing content.
Speaking to RedShark News, "The Brutalist" editor Jancsó defended their use of Respeecher: "AI allows us to streamline intricate processes," he explained, emphasizing the need to properly understand technology's role in the film industry. Director Corbet further clarified to Variety that the performances remained authentic, with AI modifications limited to Hungarian pronunciation accuracy.
Broader Implications for the Industry
These developments raise important questions about the Academy Awards' dual responsibility of celebrating artistic achievement while protecting creative integrity. The industry has previously embraced films utilizing advanced technologies, such as "Bohemian Rhapsody" and "The Irishman," but the exponential growth of AI capabilities has intensified concerns about preserving human creativity.
Peter Csathy, president of Creative Media consulting firm, captured the essence of the debate: "The Oscars must balance celebrating great art with protecting creators' rights." This balance is further tested by films like "Maria," starring Angelina Jolie and Haluk Bilginer, which received a Best Cinematography nomination despite using Respeecher to recreate Maria Callas's voice.
Looking Forward
As the film industry continues to evolve, the conversation around AI in filmmaking extends beyond technical capabilities to encompass ethical considerations and creative authenticity. The success of "Emilia Perez" and "The Brutalist" at the Academy Awards may set important precedents for how the industry approaches AI integration in future productions.
The ongoing discourse highlights the need for clear guidelines that protect artistic integrity while embracing technological advancement. As the 97th Academy Awards approach, these nominations serve as a crucial moment for the industry to reflect on the delicate balance between innovation and tradition in filmmaking.